Craft CMS vs Drupal: Which is the Best CMS for Your Website?
If you're considering taking the dive and creating a website, you'll quickly find that having the proper content management system (CMS) can have an enormous impact on the success of your website.
But with so many options out there, choosing the CMS that's right for you and your specific needs is quite a daunting task. That's why today, we are taking a deep dive into two popular CMSes—Craft CMS vs Drupal—and deciding which is the best CMS for your website.
So, if you want to dig into the pros and cons of both Drupal and Craft CMS, join us! We'll discuss pricing, ease of use, SEO friendliness, and much more. Whether you're a seasoned professional or a newbie to the world of website building, our guide will set you up for success. Let's get started!
Find out why we're Craft CMS developers
Spoiler alert. We don't use Drupal – we use Craft CMS.
Quick Insight into Key Points
Craft CMS is a modern, flexible content management system that is ideal for simple websites or blogs. Drupal is a more powerful CMS, capable of handling complex web applications, with more customization and addressable features.
Introduction to Craft CMS and Drupal
Craft CMS and Drupal are two of the most popular content management systems (CMS) available today. Both have the ability to create powerful, robust websites without requiring the user to be particularly tech-savvy. However, each Content Management System has particular strengths and weaknesses that lead some web developers and website owners to prefer one over the other.
Craft CMS is a relatively new entrant into the CMS market. It was developed with an emphasis on flexibility and power, enabling users to create beautiful websites with fine control over aesthetics, content structure, and data types. Craft also places a strong emphasis on security, making it ideal for mission-critical websites.
Drupal, by comparison, has been around longer than Craft CMS – having started out in 2001. Drupal’s strength lies in its scalability; websites of any size can be built using its powerful modules allowing nearly any feature imaginable. Additionally, its large user base has enabled the development of third-party themes, plugins, and integrations which can add more value to your website.
However both tools have their weaknesses: Craft’s relative newness means that it lacks third-party integrations; while Drupal’s complexity means a steep learning curve for those without programming experience.
This article will briefly assess both platforms when it comes to creating and editing content - but first let's look at how they both compare when it comes to underlying architecture and features. With this information we can make a more informed decision as to which CMS is best for our web project.
Next section: Creating and Editing Content with Craft CMS and Drupal
Key Points
Craft CMS and Drupal are popular Content Management Systems that have particular strengths and weaknesses that lead some web developers and website owners to prefer one over the other. Craft CMS is relatively new, but places an emphasis on flexibility and power, with a strong focus on security; while Drupal has been around longer, and its strength lies in its scalability and a wealth of third-party themes, plugins, and integrations. The article will assess both platforms for creating and editing content and provide more details to help make an informed decision about which CMS is best for a web project.
A comparison table of features for Craft CMS and Drupal:
| Feature | Craft CMS | Drupal |
|---|---|---|
| User-friendly content editing | Yes | Yes |
| Templating | Twig | PHP, HTML |
| Plugins & Add-ons | Large library of third-party plugins available | Large library of third-party modules available |
| Scalability | High scalability, with the ability to handle large amounts of content and traffic | Can handle large amounts of content and traffic, but may require additional resources for scalability |
| Customization | High level of customization through Twig templates, plugins and the Craft API | High level of customization through modules and themes |
| Performance | Excellent performance due to caching, database optimizations and fast front-end loading | Can be slow due to complex architecture and database queries, but performance can be improved with caching and optimization techniques |
| SEO-friendliness | Good SEO-friendly features, including customizable URLs and meta information | Good SEO-friendly features, with additional features available through modules |
| Security | Strong security features, with regular security updates and patches | Strong security features, with regular security updates and patches |
| Support & Documentation | Large community support, with good documentation | Large community support, with good documentation |
Creating and Editing Content with Craft CMS and Drupal
Creating and editing content is one of the most fundamental pieces of designing, building, and managing a website. Consequently, understanding the differences between Craft CMS and Drupal when it comes to content authoring is essential.
Craft CMS boasts an intuitive content editor that aims to make online authorship as easy as possible. The visual interface gives content creators an at-a-glance view of the entire page layout and allows changes to be made without any coding experience. Additionally, Craft CMS allows for ‘sections’ to be created which group related content together for easier management.
Drupal offers an extremely powerful admin interface for creating and editing content. Its built-in editor has some of the most robust features available in a content management system, such as WYSIWYG editing, drag and drop functionality, multimedia support, metadata capabilities and more. This makes Drupal well suited for more advanced web development projects that require additional customization options. However, Drupal may not be suitable for inexperienced users who prefer a visually-oriented interface when crafting their pages due to its complex layout and set-up process.
Overall, both Craft CMS and Drupal offer solid backends for creating and managing content depending on your level of experience or project requirements. In terms of ease of use and customizability, Craft CMS edges out slightly ahead thanks to its user-friendly visual interface and section organization system. On the other hand, Drupal will give users the benefit of more powerful editing tools making it better suited for those who need extra control over their end product.
Given their respective strengths and weaknesses in generating content, now let’s take a look at what these two platforms have to offer when it comes to backend content editing.
Backend Content Editing
Backend Content Editing is one of the core features offered by these two content management systems, Craft CMS and Drupal. They both allow users to control their website’s content from the backend in order to easily create, update and publish content for their audiences.
Craft CMS has a streamlined and user-friendly interface that makes it easy for authors to find and edit content from the entry editor. The entry editor looks like a clean white canvas, allowing authors to focus on what they care about most – their content. It also includes features like drag & drop image uploading, and an inline spellchecking tool.
Drupal provides a large collection of modules and page builders which make it possible to author pages quickly and easily. It also has handy tools such as revision tracking, so authors can view old versions of a page before publishing changes. The downside, however, is that the UI can be intimidating due to its complexity, which can make it harder to navigate.
Overall, depending on your own needs as an author, either Craft CMS or Drupal can work great for backend content editing. Companies who are looking for an easier experience should consider Craft CMS since it offers a user-friendly interface with helpful tools already built-in. On the other hand, companies who need more control over their content should look into Drupal for its powerful set of modules and page builders.
With this comparison of backend content editing between Craft CMS and Drupal finished, let's now tackle an equally important feature: drag & drop page editing.
Drag and Drop Page Editing
Drag and drop page editing is one of the key criteria when choosing a content management system (CMS) for a website. Both Craft CMS and Drupal offer some degree of drag and drop page editing, but it’s important to consider which benefits each system provides most effectively.
Craft CMS offers advanced drag and drop page editing that can personalize content for each user with an intuitive interface. All types of users - whether they be tech-savvy or not - can manage and style their content with precision, making it perfect for web designers looking to create unique experiences. The pages are also optimized in terms of performance, speed and SEO.
Drupal's drag and drop page building capabilities come in a form of a tiled-based interface that allows users to add, edit, rearrange, customize and add elements to the pages themselves. This is beneficial for developers who are comfortable coding HTML and CSS as they can quickly assemble websites without having to write any code. Additionally, many themes designed for Drupal feature options such as background images, color palettes, animations, overlay effects and so on - allowing for the creation of visually appealing sites at ease.
In conclusion, both platforms provide useful drag and drop page building features that make designing websites easier. However, it ultimately comes down to user preference when deciding which platform suits the project best. If the goal is creating lifelong relationships with the users through tailored experiences, Craft CMS delivers better too. On the other hand if optimization of resources is a priority then Drupal may be suitable as it requires minimal code inputting due to its intuitive drag-and-drop feature.
Moving forward, let's take a closer look at how Craft CMS and Drupal can help you craft digital experiences for your website visitors.
Crafting Digital Experiences with Craft CMS and Drupal
When contrasting Craft CMS with Drupal, it quickly becomes obvious that both solutions offer digital experiences in their own unique ways. As two of the most popular content management systems (CMSs) available today, they each have their share of advantages and disadvantages.
Craft CMS is known for its user-friendly interface and comprehensive features that allow you to create customized digital experiences. Its intuitive menu structure and drag-and-drop functionality make it easy to organize your content, create dynamic landing pages, and quickly develop custom web applications. Additionally, Craft CMS offers numerous tools for optimizing images, HMTL/CSS to improve website performance, and a flexible system for deploying websites locally or in production environments. Furthermore, Craft's "Live Preview" feature keeps changes synced to the front end for real-time customization, giving users more control over their workflows.
On the opposite side of the coin is Drupal which offers an equally powerful set of tools for creating interactive digital experiences. Unlike Craft, Drupal has decades of active development under its belt making it one of the most robust open-source CMSs available today. Thanks to its modular structure, developers can easily extend its capabilities by 'plugging' in new modules to customize functionalities without having to write additional code. Additionally, Drupal is highly scalable — an important point if you plan on hosting content-heavy websites and expect a high amount of traffic.
Overall, when comparing Craft CMS vs Drupal both solutions offer powerful sets of features to help craft digital experiences — albeit through different approaches. A key takeaway here is that understanding your technical goals before implementing either solution rely heavily on your needs; just remember that certain features are more suited for certain types of projects. To further understand how these two systems differ from one another as well as look at their respective customization capabilities, read on to the next section.
Customization Capabilities
When it comes to customization capabilities, both Craft CMS and Drupal have quite a bit of potential. It all depends on the complexity of the website that is being built and the types of customizations that will be needed.
Craft CMS is great for those who need more control over their web development process. A Craft CMS development agency like Honcho can craft dynamic website templates with ease, and by leveraging Twig templating language, they can customize everything they need in order to deliver an intuitive site that meets all of their users' needs. With its small codebase and excellent abstracting capabilities, Craft CMS enables developers to build complex sites without deep coding knowledge.
Similarly, Drupal also comes with many customization options, allowing developers to adjust page design and structure using blocks, modules, themes, and templates. However, Drupal may require a deeper understanding of coding than Craft CMS as Drupal is built on more complex technology such as HTML5 markup and PHP scripting language. Therefore it may require some additional exploration into the code in order to get the most out of its features; this could be beneficial for more experienced users who don't mind getting their hands dirty with complex programming tasks.
Overall, both Craft CMS and Drupal offer users tremendous flexibility when it comes to customizing their websites. Depending on the complexity of the website being built and the user’s skillset, either platform could potentially be a great choice for creating a complete customized website experience.
Now let's consider scalability with Craft CMS and Drupal. Both platforms can be scaled to meet growing demand while maintaining speed and good performance. In the next section we'll compare how each platform handles scalability challenges so users can determine which one best suits their needs.
Scalability with Craft CMS and Drupal
Whether building a simple blog or an expansive eCommerce website, there are many factors to consider when choosing the best CMS for your website. The scalability of a given CMS can greatly influence the success of your project and its accuracy in meeting customer needs. In this article, we will be comparing the scalability of Craft CMS and Drupal - two popular open source content management systems on the market today.
Drupal is hailed as one of the most powerful content management systems when it comes to scalability due to it’s incredibly robust database structure. This database allows users to quickly create and add content across multiple channels without impacting performance, functionality or security. Additionally, Drupal makes scaling up easy by allowing you to simply add modules such as additional databases, search functions or forums. These features can easily be integrated into web applications, making them highly customisable for your needs.
On the other hand, Craft CMS is known for its flexibility when it comes to scaling. Its modular approach provides developers with numerous options when building websites, enabling customised configurations and features that can be adapted down the line as customers evolve their digital presence. Furthermore, Craft CMS offers integration for ‘Custom Element Types’ - allowing users to build custom page elements that automatically get synced from one server to another when changes are made. This also makes maintaining multiple locales of your site easier than ever before.
It’s clear to see that both Craft CMS and Drupal have their own unique benefits when it comes to scalability. While Drupal boasts a greater number of configurable options out-of-the-box, Craft CMS leads the way in terms of flexibility and customisation potential - especially for those who are willing to invest the time in getting into its more technical depths.
Next we will delve further into the capabilities of these two CMS systems by looking at data downloads and data handling capabilities with Craft CMS and Drupal.
Data and Downloads with Craft CMS and Drupal
When it comes to managing data and downloads, both Craft CMS and Drupal are well-equipped to handle these tasks. Craft CMS allows site administrators the flexibility to design custom content types and fields to store, sort, and manage any type of data they need. Craft CMS also provides an efficient way to build file and image uploads into their data structure. On the other hand, Drupal provides similar features as Craft CMS such as content types, fields, file upload capabilities, etc., but its back-end administration can get quite complex with larger websites.
At first glance it may appear that Craft CMS is the more powerful choice for storing data and downloads on a website—many users report it has a smoother UI/UX when creating and managing content. However, in terms of quantity of downloads Drupal has an edge over Craft due to its range of available modules specifically designed for this purpose while Craft remains limited in this capacity—though integration with third-party plugins offset this benefit to some extent. Regardless of which CMS is used, ensuring secure transfer protocols for sensitive files should be prioritized in any website’s development process.
Overall, either option can provide the tools needed for managing data and downloads on a website—the efficacy of each depends on whether the project is better suited for a highly customized platform (Craft) or a large feature pool (Drupal). Now that we have looked at the data and download features of both Craft CMS and Drupal, let's move onto our final thoughts about which is the best CMS for your website.
- Craft CMS and Drupal both offer a variety of features to web developers such as content creation, editing, and management capabilities.
- Craft CMS is tailored for small to medium sized businesses, while Drupal is more suited for large and complex websites.
- According to a survey in 2020, 43% of users prefer Craft CMS due to its user friendly interface and powerful features compared to Drupal.
Final Thoughts on Craft CMS vs Drupal
Choosing the right content management system (CMS) for a website can be a difficult decision. Craft CMS and Drupal are two popular options that offer different benefits and features to users, so it’s important to understand the strengths of each one before making a decision.
Craft CMS is known for its user-friendly interface, which makes it an ideal choice for creating visually appealing sites without needing advanced coding skills. It also offers features such as multilingual support and custom fields that can help enhance users’ experiences. On the other hand, Drupal offers more flexibility than Craft CMS, allowing developers to create complex solutions without being limited by pre-defined templates.
For those who need a fast and easy way to create a website or blog with limited coding experience, Craft CMS might be the right choice. For those who need more complex functionalities, additional flexibility, and scalability, Drupal could be the solution. Although both systems have their advantages and disadvantages, they can both be used to create high quality websites. It's all about finding the right one that fits your specific needs.
Answers to Common Questions with Detailed Explanations
Are there any limitations to Craft CMS that Drupal does not have?
Yes, there are some limitations to Craft CMS that Drupal does not have.
First, Craft CMS is not as customizable as Drupal when it comes to themes and plugins due to its limited options. Drupal offers more extensive features for styling and customizing your website with different themes and plugins.
Second, Craft CMS’s editor provides a user-friendly interface with structural intuitive editing capabilities that make it easier for new users to get started. However, the same can’t be said for its weaker field types and section types - compared to the broad range offered by Drupal. Additionally, its content sharing abilities are quite limited in comparison to Drupal’s stronger multisite capabilities, which allows multiple websites to be managed from one central location.
Finally, while Craft CMS offers powerful development capabilities, it favors developers more familiar with Yii (the programming language used by Craft). Drupal tends to be more familiar than Yii when it comes to web development because of its stronghold in the open source community.
Overall, these limitations should be taken into consideration when determining which content management system is the best fit for your website.
What advantages does Craft CMS have over Drupal?
Craft CMS has a few key advantages over Drupal including being more user-friendly, allowing simpler customization, and providing better security measures.
Firstly, Craft CMS is much more user-friendly compared to Drupal. The simple drag-and-drop interface makes it much easier for content creators to make changes to their websites without needing any coding knowledge. Additionally, the control panel in Craft provides a more intuitive way of managing content with helpful visual breakdowns and organized navigation.
Secondly, customizing websites with Craft is much simpler than with Drupal. There are less component parts to work with in Craft and the settings have been streamlined so that developers have fewer configurable options that are easier to manage. This means that developers can create unique solutions in Craft while spending significantly less time on the process compared to Drupal.
Finally, Craft provides stronger security measures than Drupal. With Craft, users must authenticate their passwords with both a username and email address before logging in. Also, content creators only get access to the parts of the website that they need without needing administrative access. This helps reduce potential threats from malicious actors trying to gain access to sensitive information.
Overall, Craft CMS is an excellent choice for those looking for a comprehensive but user-friendly CMS for their website due to its ease of use, simplified customization capabilities and advanced security measures.
What features of Drupal make it better than Craft CMS?
Drupal is an immensely powerful and feature-rich content management system. It stands out among other CMSs due to its scalability, flexibility, and great integration capabilities.
One of the most useful features that Drupal offers is its wide array of modules and themes. With so many modules available, Drupal allows you to quickly expand the functionality of your website. Plus, Drupal has a great selection of high-quality themes for a variety of industries that allow you to customize the look and feel of your website with ease.
Another advantage of using Drupal is its security features. With Granular permissions and various built-in security tools, Drupal lets administrators control user access level which can help make sure that only authorized users can access restricted areas. Compared to Craft CMS where user roles are limited, Drupal provides much more enhanced security controls.
Finally, Drupal also provides excellent support services through both the official forums and external software providers. With a vibrant open source community that consists of experienced developers and experts around the world contributing their time to improve the system, help is always easy to find when needed. This makes Drupal an excellent choice for organizations or businesses seeking comprehensive customer support services for their website.
Also see
Matt has been designing for the web since 1999. He loves mountain biking, watching Formula 1 and making music.